Hi,
Am new to the hobby, have just built my first detectors - two Hammerheads - and am trying to figure out why I'm getting results that seem to be sub-par...
As I mentioned, the detectors - I should point out I've only tested one so far - are Hammerheads built using Carl's guide (great guide and project... have enjoyed building it a lot). Here's the problem I have:
From viewing several threads in the coil section and the HH section, it seems that most of the outcomes for completed HH detector have average test results of at least:
9-13" detect distance in air for conductive metals (iron, coins, etc.), and
8-12" detect distance for low-conductance metals (gold rings, etc.)
I'm only getting a max of:
5-8" in air for conductive metals
3-5" in air for my gold ring (I suppose wedding bands are a common test item...)
During the build process all tests outlined in Carl's project instructions passed and the results were very close to those published. I built the monocoil per the HH instructions - 2 sets actually: one I used copper mesh on as shield but failed to leave a gap between shield & coil and upon testing could not detect a gold ring at all... and the latest one is still bare. 26 AWG w/ 26 windings and a diam. of 10.5". My damping resistor was sized for a 500 uH coil (the ideal outcome of the instructions). The build coil actually measured about 470-480 uH (was a few weeks ago so I can't remember the exact value) but in doing the calculations for resistor size for 480 it came out SO close to the 680 ohms prescribed I kept it.
The coil - which gave the above results - is wound so as to be flat in the vertical sense (one winding stack on top of the another).
My question: How critical is the shape of the coil - basket wind vs flat coil vs flat stack (or whatever one would call it... one winding atop another), etc. - in a PI detector?
As a total novice, I don't know if I should first focus time on the coil - and if so what should be changed/improved on it - in trying to find the cause of my poor results, or the PCB mounted electronics (which I suspect less as all the tests during the build gave good results)...
Any guidance/advice would be appreciated.
Malac
Am new to the hobby, have just built my first detectors - two Hammerheads - and am trying to figure out why I'm getting results that seem to be sub-par...
As I mentioned, the detectors - I should point out I've only tested one so far - are Hammerheads built using Carl's guide (great guide and project... have enjoyed building it a lot). Here's the problem I have:
From viewing several threads in the coil section and the HH section, it seems that most of the outcomes for completed HH detector have average test results of at least:
9-13" detect distance in air for conductive metals (iron, coins, etc.), and
8-12" detect distance for low-conductance metals (gold rings, etc.)
I'm only getting a max of:
5-8" in air for conductive metals
3-5" in air for my gold ring (I suppose wedding bands are a common test item...)
During the build process all tests outlined in Carl's project instructions passed and the results were very close to those published. I built the monocoil per the HH instructions - 2 sets actually: one I used copper mesh on as shield but failed to leave a gap between shield & coil and upon testing could not detect a gold ring at all... and the latest one is still bare. 26 AWG w/ 26 windings and a diam. of 10.5". My damping resistor was sized for a 500 uH coil (the ideal outcome of the instructions). The build coil actually measured about 470-480 uH (was a few weeks ago so I can't remember the exact value) but in doing the calculations for resistor size for 480 it came out SO close to the 680 ohms prescribed I kept it.
The coil - which gave the above results - is wound so as to be flat in the vertical sense (one winding stack on top of the another).
My question: How critical is the shape of the coil - basket wind vs flat coil vs flat stack (or whatever one would call it... one winding atop another), etc. - in a PI detector?
As a total novice, I don't know if I should first focus time on the coil - and if so what should be changed/improved on it - in trying to find the cause of my poor results, or the PCB mounted electronics (which I suspect less as all the tests during the build gave good results)...
Any guidance/advice would be appreciated.
Malac
Comment