Nokta Simplex copy White's MXT? Why?

[Taktyk]

Hi,

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vjhDP4Rfj2o

Comparison schematic:

http://www.taktykpulse.com.pl/2019/0...s-makro-racer/

Why this way is good...?

Regards
TAKTYK

[kt315]

microscopic pics you want i ll blind.

this way is not good

[Funfinder]

Stop spreading false rumors which only are created
by evil persons to harm their competitors because
they are jealous of their inventions and success!

HELP, Samsung it the copycat of Siemens washing-
automat because it also works with water! *laugh*

[Taktyk]

Inventios, really?

I'm a big fan of the White's company. I don't like anyone copying their solutions, technical thought, anything... This is not a good way. Where is decency and honesty?

T.

[Taktyk]

Here is schematic MXT - my schematic, reverse engineering:



Now shematic Makro Racer, from this forum:



Identical chanels structure and junctions, from multiplexer 4053, trough opamp to 4531 (sampling), to ADC converter ADS8320. This is identical.

T.

[WM6]

You are right.

But why inventing something new, if it can be stolen with impunity from other creative genuine inventors?

At the end Rutus (assume well known to you?) muddle the same thing around Whites schematics, solutions and ideas.

[Orbit]

They all steal both whites and blacks MD3030 - Fiser 1235 mxt - macro2
golden mask - miladinka - vave - enigma
etc!https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2F0JbjinerY be like the GURU!

[Taktyk]

I don't now... Inspiration is something different from copy and paste (1:1)

T.

[Funfinder]

With my philosophical knowledge I could give you funny examples concerning
the topic what is "theft" - perhaps at the offtopic forum. *laugh*

I guess that many engineers not even are knowing terms like "all rights reserved by the inventor" -
wasn't already Edison stealing the ideas of Tesla and afterwards made big money with his
lightbulbs?

They are professionalists and wanna improve their devices and use for this the inspirations
or what they are capable of understanding with their often pretty limited mind! *laugh*

These MD-circuits are since 30 years more or less the same - some little improvements
here, some a few better improvements there. In other words: There is not much choice
as long as you don't focus on some total new EM-field-detection area as GPR etc. does.

[kt315]

With my philosophical knowledge
---
which? Marx-Lenin dialectical materialism? what philo knowledge you got in your high school?

[Carl-NC]

I'm a big fan of the White's company. I don't like anyone copying their solutions, technical thought, anything... This is not a good way. Where is decency and honesty?

Even White's is guilty. The Classic series was largely a copy of the Tesoro 2-filter design.

[Orbit]

Mileva Maric steals ideas from Albert Anstein ETC

[dbanner]

Even White's is guilty. The Classic series was largely a copy of the Tesoro 2-filter design.

The very first Minelab detector(or one of their very early models ) was a copy of the whites 5000D circuit. They made huge circuit board and had tracks running like the Kentucky derby-round and round-but it was the same 5000D circuit.
Don't know if it was under license or not. Maybe they had permission to do so.

[dbanner]

edited

[Funfinder]

Instead of insulting Makro / Nokta you better should ask why no manufacturer from
Europe, America, Australia etc. offered induction balance MDs with 50cm & 1m coils,
with vibration, with search-light, with 2D or 3D imaging, waterproofed and and and.