Originally posted by Ultimate_Haze
View Post
yes the bigger the coil... and you'll get some more depth... BUT remember that big coils need big targets (so in your case big coins).
I say that cause maybe this detail was not considered in latest posts.
If you have to look for small coins I think the best of best is anything from 20cm to 27cm. In TGS I found that the optimum compromise is Ivconic's size... dear old DD 10 or 11' not more.
The coin I used for tests on big coil is big: >32mm diameter, UK half-crown of 1967...copper-nickel alloy... not anymore in production... can see one similar in picture. Mine is that way...
You have to consider that the field shape is different in large coils... then the lines density is different for a fixed amount of power at tx.
Happens, then, you need more exposed target surface to flux in larger coils to gain the response you need... and that's expecially true on small items like coins. With larger objects like a coke can the larger coils work pretty well and you get a very effective increase of range... but we are talking of small stuff here.
The other side effect is the increased ground influence on big coils... so you could end-up on soil with lowered S/N on 12' than with smaller coil say 10' or 11' range.
But the increase on large coin is not speculation... you see it both on air and into the ground... just the approach must then fit in your searching scenario... so if look for smaller stuff stay with smaller coil cause larger will give you more troubles than advantages.
As an example... I use maybe 90% times Ivconic's coil... and (maybe) 5% my larger coil on TGS...
Optimize RX ? lower noise front-end... fix instability and noise propagation on board... use different parts... put one-shot at end of audio path: that way you could increase gain and leave tx power as before... the reduced noise will increase S/N... you can run at increased gain, max sensitivity with no or minimum chatters and then get far/weak signals more easy... that could mean a gain of >5cms detection range (maybe!) on 20-25mm range coin on 10' coil.
That's not bad... that way you could break the 40cm range on 1eur with a 10' coil... but you may ask Ivconic about advantages and troubles related e.g. to the one-shot (monostable) at the end of chain... like poor pinpointing etc

Kind regards,
Max
Comment