comparison

[metaldetector107]

To all friends

could you possible compare these MD's from good to the Best with best greetings

1-RH
2-white eagle specrum
3-XP golmaxx power
4-Explorer SE
5-DFX
6-Spectra v3
7-E-trac
8-White's Eagle IIc

kind regrads

[kt315]

not not and not!

why you there people are not waking up that Minelab HAD DID the revolution in metaldetecting? in Terra's they use a new superior property - analog-to-digital conversion IN A COIL INSIDE. they has refused poly-frequencied way in advantage oldie-famous GOLD interrelation SIGNAL/NOISE! so Whites Vision is great machine... but Minelab has give new superior advantage to this time novaday! you all will be witnesses as I am right and Whites second one will be 'Terra technology' one only!
there is not a magic in the world! only be on ONE STEP FORWARD than anothers!

[ivconic]

.

[Max]

there's always black magic...

I need a dead chicken now !

[ivconic]

.

[metaldetector107]

comparison

Dear Max Ivconic

please whats wrong with you i never expect you to not to answer!!!!!!
so please give me your opinion about above listed MD's

regrads

[WM6]

Dear Max Ivconic

please whats wrong with you i never expect you to not to answer!!!!!!

As I can see Max answered to you and ivconic even twice.

If this is not enough than you maybe need more to explain what does "from good to the Best" mean for you.

Probably you need first to evaluate for yourself "from good to the Best" some main MD feature you prefer like: main purpose of MD, design, weight, battery life, air test, field test, discrimination, selectivity, targets response time, target ID deep, pinpointing, target deep determination, surf search suitability, under water search suitability, land search suitability, target ID availability (voice, meter, number), quality of made, price, after buy support - service, coils available etc., and then ask for comparison score.

At present state of the art, we can only claim that NYD metal detector regarded as "the Best" MD ever.

[metaldetector107]

comparison

Dear WM6

you are right actually i want your opinion about deepest and acurate discrimination among above listed MD's

best regrads

[WM6]

Dear WM6

you are right actually i want your opinion about deepest and acurate discrimination among above listed MD's

best regrads

In one other thread here ivconic give us very good review about Explorer SE regarding both your criteria.

It depend of selected coil too, so probably with proper coil (e.g. Excellerator 12") listed Whites series can be equal or even better in question of deep and disc. By Spectra v3 you can expect more user friendly approach at same results.

[ivconic]

WM6 don't waste your time; man is total idiot. I already received dozen pm's with same old questions, all over again and again. Total idiot with bad intentions or maybe that much brainless that is overcomes all our expectations! Simply disregard this damn fool!
Sooner or later he will disappear......hopefully!

[Carl-NC]

in Terra's they use a new superior property - analog-to-digital conversion IN A COIL INSIDE. they has refused poly-frequencied way in advantage oldie-famous GOLD interrelation SIGNAL/NOISE!

I don't think X-Terra coils have an ADC inside. They have a micro that tells the detector what kind of coil it is so the detector can select the right frequency, but the coil otherwise operates as an ordinary coil.

- Carl

[metaldetector107]

comparison

Dear Ivconic
i am not so fool as you think, my problem is to much confusion here
for example i red your post about explorer se tests which you were unable to detect a coin at 30cm underground except larger excelerator coil,
also you and your friend once dug a oil lamp at about 90cm with very good disc using RH!!!! i think 90cm is very good!!!
about eagle spectrum i red yor post also comaring with TGSL your post says TGSL is better coinshooting but cant compare with white eagle specrum 180cm in air 180??!!!! very deep even large object' Qiauozhe and Max said non of VLF can detect a hoard at 1m so
i think all of you agry and MD will lose its depth 30% in ground to air test?
180cm mean 110 at leat underground for big object. how big????

again Ivconic please do not get me wrong if to many same question.

best regrads

[ivconic]

You must be! You are persistent in asking same question again and again.
There is not one, unique, perfect detector - no such thing. Each mentioned model has drawbacks and benefits. Each one is story of itself. Each one can perform good or bad in given conditions.
You are asking for one and only model to suit all your possible demands! That is very stupid. I am tired repeating same answers again and again. Last month or two nothing interesting on this forum, only you asking again same questions.
Here is Carl, maybe you should ask him about new Spectra. Maybe is Spectra right choice for you?
But i am afraid that you are not real customer, more like that you are just empty "talker" !

[kt315]

I don't think X-Terra coils have an ADC inside. They have a micro that tells the detector what kind of coil it is so the detector can select the right frequency, but the coil otherwise operates as an ordinary coil.

- Carl

I did think in this clue too... one man opened a coil... the all coil has a micro with integrated TX generator and ADC. it is clear... on TX coil is sinusoidal signal 20V AC, on RX coil is also sinusoidal following in the micro. from the chip a signal comes out already as kinda digital, discrete. I changed my opinion...

[WM6]

Nice finding KT315. Thanks for posting here.

This does not mean that this "ADC" micro solution is so superior over other detectors, but for sure multifrequency solution is inferior at least in domain of common deep range in soil.

Maybe this "ADC" has something to do with the so-called coil saturation and nothing else.